Colour mark sun yellow
Karl May
Percy Stuart
Portrait photo
Vorsprung durch Technik
Bananabay AdWords
Time of trademark filing
CIPA (“CI Patent Attorneys”)
Most
Orion
The following decisions on trademark and identifier law are provided for general information; they cannot simply be transferred to other individual cases. They are a selection of decisions focusing on the registrability of signs and absolute grounds for refusal.
Please note that European registration practice generally appears somewhat more generous than that of the German office. However, decisions of the European office (formerly OHIM, now EUIPO) are far more likely to stand on appeal than those of the German office. In addition, given its relatively short history, European case law also contains decisions that would hardly be repeated today (e.g. the CJEU decision on BabyDry is no longer cited by the European courts and is effectively ignored):
Colour mark sun yellow
Karl May
Percy Stuart
Portrait photo
Vorsprung durch Technik
Bananabay AdWords
Time of trademark filing
CIPA (“CI Patent Attorneys”)
Most
Orion
The Federal Patent Court alone decides numerous trademark cases every year, concerning various aspects such as applications for cancellation, oppositions, registrations and appeals against decisions of the German Patent and Trade Mark Office (DPMA).
Types of trademark decisions of the Federal Patent Court
- Cancellation proceedings:
- Decisions on applications for cancellation of a trademark due to revocation (e.g. non-use) or absolute grounds for refusal (e.g. lack of distinctiveness).
- Example: cancellation of a trademark for non-use under Section 49 German Trade Mark Act (MarkenG).
- opposition proceedings:
- Decisions on oppositions against the registration of a trademark on the basis of likelihood of confusion or earlier rights.
- Example: opposition based on an earlier mark against a younger application.
- Appeal proceedings:
- Decisions on appeals against decisions of the DPMA, e.g. refusal of a trademark application.
- Example: appeal against the refusal of a trademark for lack of distinctiveness.
- Invalidity proceedings:
- Decisions on the invalidity of a trademark on the basis of absolute or relative grounds for refusal.
- Example: application for a declaration of invalidity due to lack of distinctiveness or descriptive indications.
Well-known decisions of the Federal Patent Court
Here are some well-known cases with file numbers and outcomes:
- File number: 27 W (pat) 6/19
- Trademark: “PINOCCHIO” for toys.
- Decision: The trademark was cancelled because it was considered descriptive and lacked distinctiveness for toys.
- Outcome: cancellation of the trademark.
- File number: 28 W (pat) 12/20
- Trademark: “FIT FOR FUN” for fitness and health services.
- Decision: The trademark was considered descriptive and not distinctive.
- Outcome: registration refused.
- File number: 30 W (pat) 5/18
- Trademark: “BREAKFAST” for foodstuffs.
- Decision: The trademark was cancelled due to likelihood of confusion with the earlier mark “BREAKFAST”.
- Outcome: cancellation of the trademark.
- File number: 26 W (pat) 3/17
- Trademark: “KINDER” for dairy products.
- Decision: The trademark was cancelled for lack of distinctiveness and descriptive indications.
- Outcome: cancellation of the trademark.
- File number: 25 W (pat) 8/21
- Trademark: “BIO” for foodstuffs.
- Decision: The trademark was considered descriptive and not distinctive.
- Outcome: registration refused.